# CNIL Cookie Fines: The Banner Mistakes Behind 23 New Sanctions

CNIL cookie fines keep coming: 23 simplified sanctions since January 2026. The ordinary cookie banner mistakes behind them, and what the CNIL expects instead.

By Jasper Koers · Published 2026-07-07

## Key takeaways

- On 6 July 2026 the CNIL announced 23 sanctions under its simplified procedure since January 2026, for a total of €133,750, with 19 of them originating from complaints.
- The CNIL's simplified sanction procedure is used for less complex cases, caps each fine at €20,000 and does not publish the name of the sanctioned organisation.
- In the July 2026 batch, the CNIL found cookie banners that did not explain purposes, advertising cookies placed before any user action, and banners where accepting took one click while refusing required "personnaliser" and further steps.
- The CNIL requires that refusing cookies is as easy as accepting them, so a site with a one-click "accept all" button must also offer a one-click way to refuse all.
- The CNIL found the cookie breaches in its July 2026 sanctions through online checks of websites, including online ticket sellers and telemarketing companies.

> **Not legal advice.** This article explains public CNIL decisions and guidance. For your own situation, talk to a privacy lawyer or your DPO.

On 6 July 2026 the French data protection authority, the CNIL, [announced 23 new sanctions](https://cnil.fr/fr/23-nouvelles-sanctions-simplifiees) under its simplified procedure, all issued since January 2026. Together they add up to **€133,750**, and **19 of the 23** started with a complaint. Several of them concern cookies, and the mistakes are not exotic: banners that do not explain what the cookies are for, advertising cookies that load before anyone clicks, and a "refuse" option hidden behind a "Personnaliser" button while "accept all" takes one click.

That is why this batch matters to small and mid-sized sites. These are not €100 million fines against Big Tech. They are modest, anonymous fines for the cookie banner mistakes that a large share of ordinary websites still make, found partly by the CNIL simply checking websites online.

## What the CNIL announced on 6 July 2026

The **simplified procedure** has existed since 2022. It is meant for less complex cases: a single member of the CNIL's restricted committee decides, each fine is **capped at €20,000**, and the sanctioned organisation is **not named**. The CNIL did not publish the amount for each case, only the total.

The 23 sanctions cover three areas:

| Area | What the CNIL found |
| --- | --- |
| Video surveillance and employee monitoring | Cameras without the required authorisation and cameras filming employees continuously, in fast food, urban transport and station retail |
| Data subject rights and cooperation | 8 sanctions for not honouring access or erasure requests, 4 of which also involved failing to cooperate with the CNIL |
| **Cookies** | Breaches found through online checks of several websites, including online ticket sellers and telemarketing companies |

For cookies, the CNIL relies on Article 82 of the French Data Protection Act, the French transposition of the ePrivacy rules on storing and reading information on a user's device.

## The cookie banner mistakes behind the CNIL cookie fines

The CNIL describes three types of cookie breaches in this batch.

### 1. A banner that does not say what the cookies are for

Some banners were incomplete. They did not explain the **purposes** of the cookies, did not identify who was responsible, and did not explain how to refuse or withdraw consent. Consent is only valid if it is informed, so a banner that just says "we use cookies to improve your experience" with an accept button does not get you valid consent.

### 2. Advertising cookies before any click

On some sites, cookies that require consent, such as advertising cookies, were placed **before the visitor did anything**. This is one of the most common problems in practice: a tag manager or ad script fires on page load, and the banner only appears afterwards. In the CNIL's view, nothing that needs consent may be stored or read until the visitor has actually said yes.

### 3. Accepting takes one click, refusing takes several

The pattern the CNIL keeps coming back to: a prominent **"Tout accepter"** button on the first screen, while refusing means clicking **"Personnaliser"**, going to another screen and switching off settings one by one. The CNIL repeated its position plainly: if you offer one click to accept all cookies, you must offer one click to refuse them all.

## Cookie banner checklist: mistake vs what the CNIL expects

The table below combines the breaches in this batch with the CNIL's published [guidance and FAQ on cookies and other trackers](https://www.cnil.fr/fr/cookies-et-autres-traceurs/regles/cookies/FAQ).

| Common mistake | What the CNIL expects |
| --- | --- |
| Only "Accept" and "Settings" on the first layer | A "refuse all" option as easy as "accept all", ideally a "tout refuser" button at the same level and in the same style |
| Refusing requires a second screen and toggles | Refusal on the same screen, with the same effort as consent |
| Vague text like "to improve your experience" | Every purpose presented before the user chooses, each with a short, visible title and description |
| Ad or tracking tags fire on page load | No tracker that needs consent before valid consent is given |
| Scrolling or continuing to browse treated as consent | Consent through a clear positive action; continued browsing counts as refusal |
| No way to change your mind later | Withdrawing consent as easy as giving it, for example with a permanent "manage cookies" link or icon |
| Banner reappears on every page after a refusal | Store the choice, refusal included; the CNIL describes keeping choices for 6 months as good practice |
| "Legitimate interest" toggles pre-enabled for ad partners | Non-essential trackers still need prior consent, whatever label the interface uses |

Most of these fixes cost little. The most important one is usually the first: put a "refuse all" button next to "accept all". Our article on [how cookie consent banners hurt your conversion rate](/blog/cookie-consent-banners-are-killing-your-conversion-rate) explains why that also changes the numbers you see in your analytics.

## Why ticket sellers and telemarketing firms

The CNIL found the cookie breaches through **online checks**, not only complaints. That is worth noting: no visitor needed to complain. A regulator loading your homepage and looking at what happens before and after the banner is enough to start a case.

The sectors named, online ticket sales and telemarketing, are typical of sites that run a lot of advertising and marketing tags. The more third-party scripts a site loads, the more likely one of them fires before consent.

## Why "only €133,750" still matters

Spread over 23 sanctions, the average is under €6,000, and the names are not published. It is tempting to shrug. Three reasons not to:

- **The procedure is fast and cheap for the regulator.** A single decision-maker and a capped fine mean the CNIL can handle many small cases instead of a few big ones.
- **Complaints drive it.** 19 of the 23 cases began with a complaint. One annoyed visitor can be enough.
- **The fine is not the only cost.** Sanctions can come with orders to fix things, and in the rights cases, periodic penalty payments followed when organisations did not comply.

## Where analytics fits in

Many banners exist mainly because of analytics and ad tags. The CNIL does exempt some **audience measurement** from consent, but only under strict conditions: measurement limited to the site's own audience, used only for anonymous statistics, without cross-site tracking, without matching to other data and without passing data to third parties. The site has to be able to show it meets those conditions. Our [GDPR compliance guide for web analytics](/blog/gdpr-compliance-for-web-analytics-the-complete-guide) goes into the details.

ClearAnalytics was built for that profile: it sets no cookies, stores nothing on the visitor's device, keeps data in the EU and never shares it for advertising. It is designed so that analytics alone should not be a reason to show a banner, though if you run ad tags, your banner still has to meet every point in the table above. See [how it compares](/comparison) to other analytics tools.

## Frequently asked questions

### How much are CNIL cookie fines under the simplified procedure?

Each fine under the simplified procedure is capped at €20,000. The CNIL did not publish individual amounts for the 23 sanctions announced on 6 July 2026, only the total of €133,750.

### Is a "Refuse all" button mandatory in France?

The CNIL says refusing must be as easy as accepting. If your banner has a one-click "accept all" button, you need an equally easy one-click way to refuse, and a "tout refuser" button at the same level and in the same style is the clearest way to do that.

### Can I set advertising cookies before the visitor clicks accept?

No. The CNIL states that trackers subject to consent may not be placed on the device until valid consent has been given, and continuing to browse does not count as consent.

### What is the CNIL simplified sanction procedure?

It is a faster procedure, in place since 2022, in which a single member of the CNIL's restricted committee decides less complex cases. Fines are capped at €20,000 and the organisation is not named publicly.

### Do analytics cookies need consent under CNIL rules?

Not always. The CNIL exempts audience measurement that is strictly limited to the site's own anonymous statistics, without cross-site tracking, matching with other data or transfer to third parties. Tools that do not meet those conditions, such as those that reuse data for advertising, need consent.

Source: https://clearanalytics.eu/blog/cnil-cookie-fines-simplified-sanctions
