Privacy & GDPR

Informed Consent Cookies: noyb vs 1,741 Partners in One Click

noyb says one click on dict.cc accepts 1,741 ad partners. Can that ever be informed consent for cookies? The complaint, the VRT ruling and what to do.

By Jasper Koers Published 6 min read

On this page
  1. The noyb complaint against dict.cc
  2. Why "accept all" may not be informed consent
  3. The VRT decision: mass complaints can't be brushed off
  4. What this means for your consent prompt
  5. Where ClearAnalytics fits

On 30 July 2026, privacy group noyb filed a GDPR complaint with the Austrian data protection authority against dict.cc, the popular online dictionary. The issue is one button. According to noyb, dict.cc's consent prompt asks visitors to agree to tracking by 1,741 "partner" companies in a single click. Reading all of their privacy policies would take at least 170 hours, even if you only spent six minutes on each.

noyb's argument is simple: if nobody can know who gets their data, nobody can give informed consent. The complaint lands two weeks after the European Data Protection Board told the Belgian regulator that it may not brush off another noyb cookie complaint as an abuse of rights. Together, they put pressure on the "accept all" banner with hundreds of vendors behind it.

Not legal advice. This article describes a pending complaint and a regulator's procedural decision. Neither is a final ruling on the merits. Talk to your DPO or a lawyer about your own consent setup.

The noyb complaint against dict.cc

According to the complaint (an English auto-translation of the German original), the complainant visited dict.cc on 7 July 2026, saw a consent banner and clicked "Accept All and Visit Website" to use the dictionary. The banner's submenu listed the partners that would receive his data. noyb's announcement puts the number at 1,741; the translated complaint counts 1,721 at the time of the visit. Either way, it is far beyond what anyone can review.

The complaint makes three points:

  • No informed consent. Under Article 4(11) GDPR, consent must be "freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous". noyb argues that consent covering more than 1,700 companies cannot be informed.
  • No transparency. The partners' privacy notices are often only available in English, and several say they pass data on further. noyb calls the result a "blanket consent" for thousands of entities, some of them unknown.
  • No legal basis. Without valid consent, noyb says the processing violates Article 6(1) and the transparency principle in Article 5(1)(a).

noyb asks the Austrian authority to order dict.cc to delete the data, to inform all recipients about the deletion, and proposes a fine. It adds that the authority could issue a wider ban or refer the matter to the EDPB, given its general significance. noyb also points to repubblica.it, bergfex.de and fifa.com as examples of the same practice.

The legal standard is not new. What the complaint does is apply it to the size of modern vendor lists.

Requirement Source How a 1,741-partner banner tests it
Consent must be informed Art. 4(11) GDPR The visitor must know who gets the data and why. With 1,741 names, that knowledge is theoretical.
Information must let users determine the consequences of consent CJEU, Planet49 (C-673/17), para. 74 Consequences depend on what each partner does, and many pass data on again.
Information must be clear and plain Art. 7(2) GDPR, Recital 58 Recital 58 names online advertising as a case where many parties and complex technology make transparency hard.
Controller must be able to demonstrate consent Art. 7(1) GDPR The site has to show the click meant something, not just that it happened.
Withdrawing must be as easy as giving Art. 7(3) GDPR A single accept click needs an equally simple way to withdraw, for every partner covered.

The complaint also quotes the EDPB's consent guidelines (05/2020): without accessible information, "user control becomes illusory" and consent is not a valid basis. And it cites the Court of Justice's IAB Europe judgment (C-604/22) for the point that data in automated advertising is routinely shared onward.

Where long vendor lists come from

Lists this long are typical of programmatic advertising. Many publishers use a consent management platform built on IAB Europe's Transparency & Consent Framework (TCF), where vendors register in a shared list and a site can enable hundreds of them at once. noyb's announcement does not say which framework dict.cc uses, so we will not assume it. The structural point stands for any setup: every vendor you switch on is another name the visitor is supposedly informed about.

The VRT decision: mass complaints can't be brushed off

The second development came from the EDPB on 14 July 2026. It published a binding decision, dated 28 May 2026, in a dispute about a noyb complaint over the cookie banners on the website of VRT, the Belgian public broadcaster.

  • noyb filed the complaint with the Austrian authority on behalf of an individual. Because VRT is based in Belgium, the Belgian authority was the lead authority.
  • The Belgian authority proposed to dismiss the complaint as an abuse of the right to complain (Art. 77 GDPR) and of the right to be represented by an organisation (Art. 80(1) GDPR).
  • The Austrian authority objected: the complaint should be decided on the merits, not thrown out on procedure. Belgium did not follow the objection and sent the dispute to the EDPB.
  • The EDPB applied the Court of Justice's test for abuse and found that neither its objective nor its subjective component was shown. The complainant did not abuse their rights.
  • The Belgian authority must now assess the complaint on its merits and submit a new draft decision under Article 60(3) GDPR.

The decision says nothing yet about whether VRT's banner was lawful. But it removes an easy exit. Cookie banner complaints that are part of a wider campaign still have to be decided on what the banner actually does. For a site owner, that means a consent setup cannot rely on "they're just mass complaints" as a defence.

Neither case has been decided on the merits, so there is no new rule yet. The direction is still useful:

  1. Count your vendors. Open your own consent prompt and count the partners listed. If you could not explain what each of them does with the data, your visitors cannot either.
  2. Cut what you don't use. Vendor lists often grow by default. Every partner you remove makes the consent you ask for easier to defend.
  3. Check onward sharing. If a partner passes data on to others, those others are part of what the visitor agrees to.
  4. Make refusing as easy as accepting. Article 7(3) GDPR requires withdrawal to be as easy as giving consent. Our article on the CNIL's simplified cookie sanctions covers the banner mistakes regulators keep finding.
  5. Separate measurement from advertising. You need your traffic numbers whether or not anyone consents to ads. If your analytics depends on the same consent as your ad partners, you lose data from everyone who refuses. Google Consent Mode v2 tries to model that gap; it does not close it.

A shorter banner is also a better banner for your business. We covered the conversion cost of consent prompts in cookie consent banners are killing your conversion rate.

Where ClearAnalytics fits

ClearAnalytics is one partner fewer to explain. It sets no cookies, stores nothing on the visitor's device, keeps data in the EU and does not share visitor data with third parties or use it for advertising. It is designed so that your traffic measurement shouldn't need to sit in a consent prompt next to hundreds of ad vendors. See how it compares to other analytics tools.

Frequently asked questions

Is clicking accept all cookies valid consent under the GDPR?

Only if the consent is freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous, as GDPR Article 4(11) requires. noyb argues that an accept all button covering 1,741 partners cannot be informed, because nobody can read and understand that many privacy policies.

What is the noyb complaint against dict.cc?

A GDPR complaint filed on 30 July 2026 with the Austrian data protection authority. noyb asks the authority to order deletion of the complainant's data, notification of all recipients and a fine, and says the authority could also impose a wider ban or refer the issue to the EDPB.

How many partners can a cookie banner list?

The GDPR sets no maximum number. The test is whether visitors can understand who gets their data and what happens to it, and the more partners a banner lists, the harder that becomes to show.

Can a data protection authority dismiss mass cookie complaints?

Not simply because they are part of a campaign. In its binding decision on the VRT case, the EDPB found that the complainant did not abuse their rights and told the Belgian authority to handle the complaint on the merits.

  • cookie-consent
  • noyb
  • gdpr
  • consent-banners
  • adtech

Back to blog Read as markdown

Enjoyed this article?

Try ClearAnalytics for free and get privacy-first analytics for your website.